Your Movement Is Not a Crime

Flock Safety cameras photograph and log the license plate of every driver who passes them in Brevard County. No warrant is required to search those records, no resident was asked for consent, and the list of agencies that can query the data is not public.

The cameras are coming down, but nothing stops them going back up. Read where things stand
The Constitution Prevails. For Now.

Florida ordered the cameras off state roads

On August 31, 2026, the Florida Department of Transportation issued a memorandum revoking every existing permit for automated license plate readers installed in the right of way of the State Highway System. Agencies have 30 days to remove the devices. After that, FDOT says it will remove them itself. The department also stopped approving new installations.

FDOT wrote that the rapid growth in deployments, together with reports of misuse, data privacy concerns, and surveillance schemes, required immediate action to protect the sovereignty and quality of life of Floridians. Governor Ron DeSantis had called the spread of the readers out of control days earlier, saying he did not want Florida to become a surveillance state.

Read the coverage: WTSP, WLRN, WFTV

What Brevard County did

Sheriff Wayne Ivey announced on August 31 that the Brevard County Sheriff's Office has terminated its use of Flock cameras effective immediately. Every camera assigned to the agency, all of them along thoroughfares such as Interstate 95 and State Road 528, is to be physically removed.

He went further than the state required. BCSO also suspended its access to the wider Flock database across Brevard County, including cameras installed by private property owners, which the FDOT order does not touch.

The Space Coast Rocket

What the rest of the county did

  • Titusville Police: temporary operational pause on its Flock program, with a revised policy to be presented to the City Council. Several of its readers sit in FDOT rights of way.
  • Palm Bay: suspended its system in early August over permitting and installation problems rather than privacy, then restored it once paperwork cleared. Its cameras are on city streets and are not covered by the state order.
  • Melbourne: city street cameras fall outside the FDOT order. The council still decides this one.

Across Florida

Sheriffs responded within hours. Jacksonville, Putnam, Nassau, Clay, Liberty, Franklin, Volusia, and Flagler counties announced shutdowns or suspensions. Pasco County had already moved to end its program. Oviedo's council voted before a standing room only crowd to pull all eight of the city's cameras, and Lake County voted to revoke its permits.

Not everyone was pleased. Volusia Sheriff Mike Chitwood said he felt blindsided and that the blanket order threw the baby out with the bathwater.

Why this says "for now"

The order reaches state highway rights of way. It does not reach cameras on city streets, county roads, or private property, and roughly nine in ten readers in Florida sit somewhere other than a state road.

Nothing about the order is permanent. No statute was passed. A memo that revoked these permits can be revised by the agency that wrote it, and the sheriff has framed the shutdown as a pause pending action by the Legislature.

Private cameras keep running. Flock's contracts with homeowner associations, shopping centers, and businesses are untouched, and that data still flows into the same searchable network.

What to ask for next

A pause is not a policy. The cameras came down because the state pulled a permit, not because anyone established a right. Turning this into something durable takes three things:

  • Statutory guardrails from the Florida Legislature: a warrant requirement for searches, a short retention limit, a ban on sharing with outside and federal agencies, and published audits with real penalties for misuse
  • Local votes that outlast the memo. Melbourne, Palm Bay, and every city with cameras on its own streets should cancel by council vote rather than wait for Tallahassee
  • Public records now. Before any agency restores a program, residents should see the contract, the cost, the retention period, every agency that could query the data, and the full audit log of who searched what and why
The Deputy of the Year

Sheriff Ivey says his agency had strong policies protecting privacy: restricted access, retention limits, a required case number, and an audit system. Brevard County has already run the experiment on whether those policies stop abuse.

Michael Fultz, 2025 Brevard County Deputy of the Year

Resigned in May 2026 as the sheriff moved to fire him

Fultz was hired in 2024 and named Deputy of the Year in 2025. On the day of that honor in March, his ex-girlfriend sent the sheriff's office a letter detailing his conduct. The internal affairs investigation that followed ran 43 pages. He resigned before he could be terminated.

Among the findings reported by News 6, which obtained the records, and by 404 Media, which obtained the investigation:

  • An audit showed he searched his ex-girlfriend's license plate in the Flock database before a shift and labeled the search an investigation
  • Investigators obtained images of him placing his service weapon in his ex-girlfriend's mouth and pointing it at the back of her head during consensual sex acts
  • A photograph from 2023, taken before he was hired, showed him with his mustache shaved to resemble Adolf Hitler and appearing to perform a Nazi salute. He admitted posing for it, denied being racist, and called it a joke
  • He confirmed the authenticity of text messages in which he repeatedly used a racial slur
  • He was stopped for speeding on his motorcycle with an obscured tag at least four times and identified himself as law enforcement each time. In February, clocked at 111 mph, a trooper issued a civil citation instead of an arrest and told him they were buddies

Ivey wrote to Fultz that the nature and severity of his misconduct had irreparably damaged the trust required to perform the duties of a deputy sheriff. That is the correct judgment. It arrived only because the woman he targeted wrote a letter.

Coverage: News 6, 404 Media, The Space Coast Rocket

A Statement to Sheriff Ivey

Sheriff, you have said the pause will end when Tallahassee writes stronger controls, and that your office already had strong policies protecting the privacy of Brevard residents. Your own agency is the reason that argument fails.

Your Deputy of the Year ran your ex-girlfriend surveillance through the system you are defending. He typed the word "investigation" in the box and your audit trail let him through. The audit did not stop him. It recorded him, and only after a woman he had terrorized sat down and wrote you a letter. Everything you list as a safeguard was in place while he did it.

Please do not talk about stronger policies and reintroduction when your own department produced the exact abuse we are objecting to. The problem was never that the rules were written poorly. The problem is that a database of everywhere your neighbors drive should not exist for anyone to misuse, no matter how carefully the manual is worded.

The privacy of Floridians should not be traded for the convenience of any agency. Invest in your people, your training, and your presence in the community. Do not invest in watching the people you were elected to serve.

Deflock Brevard

The United States Constitution
We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.

The Bill of Rights, the first ten amendments to the Constitution, was ratified on December 15, 1791. These amendments were adopted to protect individual liberties and to place clear limits on the power of government over the people.

The Fourth Amendment is the one that limits how far government can reach into the private lives of citizens. It was written by people who knew what it meant to live under the eye of an overreaching state.

Amendment IV: The Right Against Unreasonable Search

"The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized."
What this means for you: Government cannot search you or seize your property without a warrant supported by probable cause. Flock cameras record where you drove and when, then hold that record in a database officers can query later. You were not suspected of anything. You were on the road. The Founders wrote the Fourth Amendment because general warrants let officials search anyone at will, and a camera network that logs the movements of an entire county works on the same principle.
Find Flock Cameras in Your Area

DeFlock.org maintains a crowdsourced map of Flock Safety and other automated license plate reader (ALPR) cameras across the United States. See where cameras are logging your movements in Brevard County and beyond.

Direct Map of Flock Cameras in Brevard County, FL Search All Cameras Nationwide at DeFlock.org
30 days
To clear Florida state rights of way
~7,500
Readers in Florida, most on local roads
1 in 3
LAPD Flock alerts found inaccurate
Contact Your County Commissioners

Brevard's five county commissioners control whether county funds go toward these programs and whether the current shutdown becomes permanent. Email them, call them, and speak at their meetings. Contact details below come from the county's own district pages.

District 1
Titusville, Mims, Scottsmoor, Cocoa, Port St. John, Canaveral Groves, Sharpes
Rita Pritchett

Phone: (321) 607-6901

Email: D1.Commissioner@BrevardFL.gov

Office: 400 South St., 4th Floor, Titusville, FL 32780

District 2
Merritt Island, Cocoa, Rockledge, Cape Canaveral, Cocoa Beach
Tom Goodson

Phone: (321) 454-6601

Email: D2.Commissioner@BrevardFL.gov

Office: Merritt Island Service Complex, 2575 N. Courtenay Pkwy, Suite 200, Merritt Island, FL 32953

District 3
Melbourne, Melbourne Beach, Palm Bay, West Melbourne, Malabar, Grant-Valkaria, Micco
Kim Adkinson Vice Chair

Phone: (321) 633-2075

Fax: (321) 633-2196

Email: D3.Commissioner@BrevardFL.gov

Office: 1311 E. New Haven Ave., Melbourne, FL 32901

District 4
Viera, Rockledge, Melbourne, Palm Shores, Satellite Beach, Indian Harbour Beach
Rob Feltner

Phone: (321) 633-2044

Email: D4.Commissioner@BrevardFL.gov

Office: 2725 Judge Fran Jamieson Way, Bldg. C, Suite 214, Viera, FL 32940

District 5
Palm Bay, Indialantic, Melbourne, West Melbourne, Melbourne Village
Thad Altman Chair

Phone: (321) 253-6611

Fax: (321) 253-6620

Email: D5.Commissioner@BrevardFL.gov

Office: 150 5th Ave., Suite D, Indialantic, FL 32903

Not sure which district you live in? Check the county's Find Your District map, or write to all five at once.

Draft Emails You Can Use

The cameras are down and the pressure should not come off. These templates ask officials to make the pause permanent instead of waiting for it to expire. Copy one, fill in the bracketed parts, and send it. Both are written to be edited, and a note that sounds like you will always land harder than one that sounds like everybody else.

To a county commissioner

Subject: Make the Flock pause permanent in Brevard County
Subject: Make the Flock pause permanent in Brevard County Dear Commissioner [NAME], I live in District [NUMBER]. I am writing about the license plate reader cameras that came down this month, and about what happens next. On August 31 the Florida Department of Transportation revoked the permits for these cameras on state roads, and Sheriff Ivey terminated the county's Flock program and cut off database access countywide. I am grateful for that. I am also aware that none of it is permanent. A memo revoked those permits and a memo can restore them. The sheriff has called this a pause and said he expects the Legislature to write rules that bring the cameras back. I am asking the Commission to make Brevard's position durable rather than temporary. Specifically: 1. Adopt a county policy that Brevard will not contract for automated license plate readers unless Florida law first requires a warrant for searches, sets a short retention limit, bars sharing with outside and federal agencies, and imposes real penalties for misuse. 2. Require a public vote of this board before any agency receiving county funds signs or renews an ALPR contract. These programs should not begin or restart through an administrative renewal. 3. Publish the record from the program that just ended: the contract and its cost, how long our data was kept, every agency that could query it, and the full audit log of who searched what and why. I want to be direct about why policies alone do not reassure me. The sheriff has said his office had strong internal safeguards, including audits requiring a case number. Brevard's own 2025 Deputy of the Year used that system to look up his ex-girlfriend's license plate and typed "investigation" in the justification field. The audit did not prevent it. It recorded it, and only after the woman he targeted wrote to the agency herself. Those safeguards were in place the entire time. A system that logs where everyone in this county drives will be misused by someone eventually. The protection I am asking for is not a better manual. It is not collecting the data. I would appreciate a written reply telling me where you stand. Thank you for your time, [YOUR NAME] [YOUR STREET ADDRESS] [YOUR EMAIL OR PHONE]

To the Melbourne City Council

Subject: Melbourne's cameras are not covered by the state order
Subject: Melbourne's Flock cameras are not covered by the state order. Please cancel the contract. Dear Mayor Alfrey and Members of the City Council, I live in Melbourne. On August 31 the Florida Department of Transportation revoked the permits for automated license plate readers in state highway rights of way, and agencies across Florida began shutting their systems down. Sheriff Ivey terminated Brevard County's program the same day. That order does not reach Melbourne's cameras. Readers on city streets sit outside the state right of way, which means this Council, and no one else, decides whether they stay. I am asking you to cancel the city's contract with Flock Safety rather than wait for Tallahassee. Before any vote, I am also asking the city to publish what it pays, how long the data is retained, every agency that can search Melbourne's cameras, and the audit records showing how many searches have been run and by whom. The reason I am not satisfied by assurances about policy is local. Brevard County's 2025 Deputy of the Year was found to have searched his ex-girlfriend's license plate in the Flock system and labeled it an investigation. The sheriff's office had access restrictions, retention limits, and an audit system requiring a case number. All of it was in place while he did it. The audit did not stop him, it recorded him, and the investigation only began because the woman he targeted wrote a letter. Melbourne cannot write a policy that fixes that, because the failure is not in the policy. It is in keeping a searchable record of where residents drive. Every camera the state ordered down came down because people showed up and asked. I am asking now. I plan to attend an upcoming Council meeting to speak on this and would welcome a reply in the meantime. Thank you, [YOUR NAME] [YOUR STREET ADDRESS] [YOUR EMAIL OR PHONE]

Before you send: change a few sentences to your own. Mention the intersection near your house, the drive you make every day, or why this matters to your family. Offices tally identical form letters as one message. A short email in your own words is read as one person, which is what you are.

Brevard County Commission Meetings

Location: Commission Chambers, Brevard County Government Center
2725 Judge Fran Jamieson Way, Building C, First Floor, Viera, FL 32940

Schedule: Regular meetings are held on Tuesdays. Agendas are posted to the county website five days before each meeting.

General info line: (321) 633-2000  |  Agenda coordinator: (321) 633-2010

Upcoming dates and agendas: brevardfl.gov/PublicMeetings  |  Meeting calendar on Legistar

Speaking at a Public Meeting

  • Fill out a speaker card before the meeting starts. You usually get three minutes
  • Open with your name and where in the county you live, then say plainly that you want the Flock contract ended
  • Name the Fourth Amendment problem: a search of everyone, all the time, with no warrant and no suspicion
  • Use documented cases rather than general worry. Officers tracking ex-partners, federal agencies querying local cameras, and audit logs nobody reviewed
  • Ask questions the board has to answer on the record. How long is the data kept, who can search it, and what has it actually solved in Brevard
  • Bring neighbors. Twelve residents on the same night carries further than twelve emails sent over a month
  • Email your commissioner a few days ahead so your position is already in writing when you stand up
Get Involved

Emails matter, and bodies in a room matter more. Here is what is happening locally and how to join it.

We have partnered with FLDR Brevard

The Florida Digital Rights Association runs a Brevard County chapter working on the same problem we are. They organize demonstrations, hand out flyers, and turn out speakers at local government meetings. If you want to plug into an existing group, start with them.

fldigitalrights.org/brevard  |  Join the Signal group chat

Every council meeting

Melbourne City Council

FLDR Brevard is committing to public comment at every Melbourne City Council meeting until the city cancels its Flock contract. Consistency is the point. A council that hears from residents once forgets. A council that hears from residents every session does not.

Next meeting: Tuesday, August 25, 2026 at 6:30 PM

Where: City Hall Council Chamber, 900 E. Strawbridge Ave., Melbourne, FL 32901

Remaining 2026 dates:

  • Tuesday, August 25
  • Tuesday, October 13
  • Tuesday, October 27
  • Tuesday, November 10
  • Tuesday, November 24
  • Tuesday, December 8

To speak or ask about the agenda: Office of the City Clerk, City.Clerk@mlbfl.org, (321) 608-7220

Meeting page  |  Agendas

Ongoing

Other Brevard Public Meetings

Flock contracts get approved by county commissions, city councils, and sometimes by boards most people have never heard of. The county keeps one calendar of all of it, and items are usually posted several days ahead.

Any time

Map a Camera

DeFlock's map is built by people who spotted a camera and reported it. If you know of an ALPR in Brevard that is not on the map yet, add it. Accurate local data is what makes the rest of this work possible.

The Fight Against Flock

Coverage of how these systems fail, how they get misused, and how communities are getting out from under them. Updated September 2026.

Track contracts and cancellations yourself: DeFlock.org maps cameras nationwide, Finding Flock keeps a running cancellation list, and Who Approved This tracks which officials voted for each contract and when it comes up for renewal.